I fucking loved this movie. It was the shit. It IS the shit. I want to see it again. Really badly. Roger Ebert is truly an idiot.
Ok, slowing down. I've always liked the feel of Silent Hill, even though the only one I actually played was the second one. I liked it more than RE, it freaked me out in the creepy holy-shit-fuck way. RE just made me just and go OH SHIT with fear of my character dying. Silent Hill filled me with deep-set dread and fear. Hellz yeh, beech.
This movie did them justice. I'll admit, the story didn't answer every question, but those unanswered questions don't bother me, especially if they make a sequel. I loved this movie, in EVERY way. They held nothing back. It was brutal, it was freaky, it was fucked up, it was awesome.
I wouldn't be surprised if this movie is more appreciated by those who played the games than those who hadn't, though.