Sara a fire mage?

[Sora]

Kid is a Red innate, and we said Sara was shadow cause magus was, but wouldnt Kid be better than magus to show us what element Sara is?

Also, for those saying those are only for elements and not magic: Kid used fire magic in RD too.

[Vehek]

The Mandora Monster uses her to cast Phantom Break, which really doesn't seem like a fire spell.

[Sora]

The Mandora Monster uses her to cast Phantom Break, which really doesn't seem like a fire spell.

at the end she uses fireball on the seed.

[Vehek]

Yeah, but Magus can use fire, ice/water, and lightning, and he's still Shadow.

[Sora]

but magus doesnt have a clone thats red innate. even guild is black

[Kyronea]

Kid is a completely different person. Though genetically identical, she most likely has a different soul, as it were, since they exist in the Chronoverse, and the Elements of Chrono Cross are representative of the music of the soul, again as it were.

Kid being Red does not render Schala a Fire Innate. Personally, I see her as a Sky Innate, but that's just me.

[Sora]

Kid is a completely different person. Though genetically identical, she most likely has a different soul, as it were, since they exist in the Chronoverse, and the Elements of Chrono Cross are representative of the music of the soul, again as it were.

Kid being Red does not render Schala a Fire Innate. Personally, I see her as a Sky Innate, but that's just me.

i say its your genintics that decide what innate you are, and since Sara and Kid are the same, their innate is the same too.

saying shes sky is baseless. saying shes fire has argument, as does shadow, abit less.

[ZealKnight]

Magus is only shadow because of Ozzie......Although I believe she is either Sky or Shadow. I also think that Kid is only Red due to Lucca raising her.

[ZeaLitY]

Genetics may determine magical innate, but Cross suggests that personality determines Elemental innate. Magic and Elements are two different systems, the latter being a derivative, watered-down version of the real thing created by Dragonians and engineered for use by Chronopolis.

[Kyronea]

Right. Kid would probably share Schala's innate element, but they'd be two different Innate Elements.

[Sora]

Right. Kid would probably share Schala's innate magic element, but they'd be two different Innate Element elements.

fixed cause it was really hard to follow ^^;;

Genetics may determine magical innate, but Cross suggests that personality determines Elemental innate. Magic and Elements are two different systems, the latter being a derivative, watered-down version of the real thing created by Dragonians and engineered for use by Chronopolis.

proof please?
for one, some people in cross have completely different personalities, and yet are same innate
also, if it was personality, than Lynx would have turned white while we had him.

[ZeaLitY]

proof please?

The innate system isn't perfect, but the very few inaccuracies can be rationalized (like Serge was depressed or jarred enough in Lynx's body to change). Innate disposition is not explained well in either game.

But if you want proof for everything else,

http://www.chronocompendium.com/Term/Scripts.html