To be bluntly honest, the answer to most of those questions is yes. Harry Potter in particular, especially when I was growing up. I'm not a fan of the "fantasy" genre of literature, so unfortunately I had to go through about 12 years(and counting) of hearing about it nonstop, while not being clued in to any of the in-jokes and references. It permeated every fiber of my childhood culture and that includes my church!
So...you had professors say your morals were skewed for not liking Harry Potter and had professors in college say Rowling was as important as Jesus and that the books were god-breathed?
"Hearing about it nonstop" and in-jokes are not the same as what I said. I've heard about a lot of things I didn't enjoy nonstop without being told they were in the same category as the Bible.
As for the Christian thing, that brings up the point that C.S. Lewis was an actual, well respected, lay theologian. Aside from his novels, he also wrote several scholarly papers about the English medieval era as well as Christian apologia.
Yes yes, I know that. We studied him in a theology course I took. I wrote a paper on
The Great Divorce.
However, being a respected theologian does not put you on the same level as people who wrote the Bible.
To criticize him for his appeal to Christians in theology is like criticizing Spenser for his appeal to Protestant and Classical symbolism(and the patrons thereof).
When on earth did I say that? I'm criticizing his fans--not him. I don't particularly care for him, but that is purely a personal preference. I said he was overrated because he is consistently compared to people who wrote the Bible and is constantly being brought up as this near-divine human being. I would describe
anyone with that kind of fanbase as being overrated, because (from a theological perspective) NO ONE can be put on the same level as the Bible. Unless God himself comes down and says "Hey, so, all the shit Lewis said was god-breathed and inerrent" then I will continue to think that he's overrated. He isn't perfect. He isn't God's mouthpiece. Thus, he's overrated in my book.
A lot of people appeal to Christians. Not everyone is treated like a saint. C. S. Lewis is treated like a saint by most of the Christians I know.
I understand it's annoying to be exposed to so much of his fanbase, but don't hate the author for his talent.
Please point out where I said that I hated Lewis. And please point out where I said I hated him for his talent.