But Ramsus, isn't linking to downloads of ROMs just about as illegal as Littering or Jaywalking? I figured it was just one of those things people would care less ab out.
It's not illegal to the point of being brought to court, is it? If that's the case, I might be in some trouble...
We're talking about hosting ROMs, not linking to them. And both of those are completely different from the acts of downloading and playing ROMs, which wouldn't make you much of a target for anything.
The problem isn't the possibility of being brought to court, but rather suddenly finding the entire hosting account for the Compendium is gone one day because Square-Enix decided just to send an e-mail asking the hosting provider to take the account down due to a blatant infringement of distributing illegal copies of their game. Most hosting providers in the US won't question something like that; they'll just delete the account.
This sort of thing usually happens for hosting music and movie clips, but it occasionally happens for software and games, and even ROMs. The reason all your favorite ROM sites don't disappear is because they're usually hosted and run overseas where nobody is going to come and drag anyone to court, so neither the hosting provider nor the owner of the site care two cents if someone sends them legal threats. And then little sites don't disappear because they aren't on the radar to begin with.
Honestly though, the only real reason we have to be careful is because we're
the Chrono series site, so if we host a ROM, we might actually get called on it due to our visibility. Besides, Square-Enix probably wouldn't like us hosting most of the stuff we already do, so they might use a ROM as clear leverage in wiping us out without so much as a single letter to any of the admins here.
Basically, it's a liability. It provides a weak spot where, if Square-Enix decided they didn't like us, they could strike us down without even trying, because it gives them the ability to simply pull our hosting out from under us while we aren't looking.