Black Sigil feels like CT mixed with FF6/ US snes FF3
I would not recommend it to anyone I know IRL. But it's perfect for me.
It's one of those extremes, where its average rating is in the middle not because it's universally seen as mediocre, rather because you'll love it or hate it.
I rather like the battle system, while the random encounters are seen as negative and the frequency is a source of complaints, it's NO worse than FF6, actually almost right on the same page..