The game I most want to see show up on the Virtual Console, since it was already officially translated into English (just not released in the US), is Terranigma.
The Virtual Console games I currently have are:
Dynastic Hero, New Adventure Island, Punch-Out!!, Sin & Punishment, Sonic the Hedgehog 2, Super Mario Bros, and Super Metroid (although I do intend to soon get Super Dodge Ball, Super Mario RPG, and Ys Book I & II)
The WiiWare games I currently have are:
Megaman 9, Strong Bad Episode 1, and Strong Bad Episode 2